Members

Ian Allan


Back to homepage

A missed call that wasn't a miss

Posted Feb. 04 at 07:56 AM

If you watch the replay of the 100-yard interception return by James Harrison in the Super Bowl, you'll see Steelers linebacker Lamarr Woodley shove Tim Hightower in the back at the 30-yard line. Without the shove, Hightower definitely would have stopped Harrison.

My initial thought was that this was a missed call -- a crucial miss.

But check the NFL rulebook, which defines clipping as the following:

Throwing the body across the back of an opponent's leg or hitting him from the back below the waist while moving up from behind unless the opponent is a runner or the contact is above the knee in close line play.

Harrison definitely engaged Hightower above the waist, so no clip.

—Ian Allan

Readers' Comments

Posted by Gregory Oswell | Feb. 04 at 08:22 AM

May not have been a clip but why wasn't it an illegal block in the back?

IAN: OK. That's a good point. I wasn't thinking of that. If you watch the replay on YouTube or at NFL.com you'll see that Woodley definitely puts both hands on Hightower's back at the 32-yard line. Hightower and Woodley definitely see each other as the play unfolds (Woodley didn't sneak up behind him, and Hightower kind of turns his back to him at the last minute), but I believe it should have been flagged as an illegal block in the back. From the NFL Rulebook, it reads as follows ... "Blocker cannot use his hands or arms to push from behind ..."

Add a Comment

Already a registered user? Please sign in to add comments.

To add comments, you must become a registered user of our site. To register, please click here.

Fantasy Index Weekly


Order your Fantasy Baseball Index 2012 now

Fantasy Baseball Index, our 116-page fantasy draft annual, includes six separate one-page cheat sheets for 4x4 and 5x5 leagues -- AL-only, NL-only and combined -- Rotisserie dollar values, stat projections, depth charts, expanded coverage of minor league prospects, three-year stats, expert opinions, strategy, team-by-team analysis and more.

AVAILABLE NOW! Order your copy and get it right away.

Order your copy now.

Past Articles

More

Toolbox