Members

Fantasy News


Back to homepage

TD-only draft: How soon is too soon for a kicker?

Posted Aug. 27 at 02:43 AM

We're into the middle rounds of the Fantasy Index TD-Only draft, which I think is where you reach a point where everyone has their eye on different players. That was especially clear when one owner selected kicker Stephen Gostkowski in the sixth round.

I am not, however, going to rip the pick. Given the format, selecting the consensus top kicker early on makes some degree of sense. Since scoring plays are all that matter, history in this league shows us that kickers are often among the leading scorers. There will be far more weeks where the top running backs get shut out than Gostkowski will.

I like some other bold picks made recently. I'm rather risk-averse when it comes to injuries, but Jonathan Stewart with the last pick of the sixth round looks pretty good to me. If healthy, he'll be a steal at that point. Eddie Royal with the first pick of the seventh also looks good; Denver might have the league's worst defense, again, and Royal might end up being their top wideout in what could be a fairly high-scoring season for the Broncos.

As for picks I wasn't crazy about, I just don't like Devin Hester at 5.09. Not in this format, not in any format. I know he could be Jay Cutler's No. 1, but it's uncertain enough to me that I wouldn't gamble on it.

The entire draft can be seen at this link; picks made thus far are presented below.

1.01    Michael Turner    (Mark Fisher)
1.02    Randy Moss    (Mark Schnzing)
1.03    DeAngelo Williams    (Mike Peterson)
1.04    Tom Brady    (Dale Grose)
1.05    Brandon Jacobs    (Adam Locke)
1.06    Adrian Peterson    (Bryan Warncke)
1.07    Maurice Jones-Drew    (Chris Adsit)
1.08    Larry Fitzgerald    (Tony Nienaber)
1.09    Marion Barber    (Jason Gingerich )
1.10    Matt Forte    (Adam London)
1.11    LenDale White    (Stewart Kuehne)
1.12    Drew Brees    (Jim O'Brien)
2.01    Brian Westbrook    (Jim O'Brien)
2.02    Peyton Manning    (Stewart Kuehne)
2.03    Aaron Rodgers    (Adam London)
2.04    Dallas Clark    (Jason Gingerich)
2.05    Steven Jackson    (Tony Nienaber)
2.06    Steve Slaton    (Chris Adsit)
2.07    LaDainian Tomlinson    (Bryan Warncke)
2.08    Calvin Johnson    (Adam Locke)
2.09    Pierre Thomas    (Dale Grose)
2.10    Reggie Wayne    (Mike Peterson)
2.11    Greg Jennings    (Mark Schnzing)
2.12    Anquan Boldin    (Mark Fisher)
3.01    Ryan Grant    (Mark Fisher)
3.02    Frank Gore    (Mark Schnzing)
3.03    Andre Johnson    (Mike Peterson)
3.04    Antonio Gates    (Dale Grose)
3.05    Marques Colston    (Adam Locke)
3.06    Kurt Warner    (Bryan Warncke)
3.07    Roddy White    (Chris Adsit)
3.08    Steve Smith    (Tony Nienaber)
3.09    Philip Rivers    (Jason Gingerich)
3.10    Terrell Owens    (Adam London)
3.11    Vincent Jackson    (Stewart Kuehne)
3.12    Cedric Benson    (Jim O'Brien)
4.01    Anthony Gonzalez    (Jim O'Brien)
4.02    Clinton Portis   (Stewart Kuehne)
4.03    Dwayne Bowe    (Adam London)
4.04    Chris Johnson    (Jason Gingerich)
4.05    Chad Ochocinco    (Tony Nienaber)
4.06    Donovan McNabb    (Chris Adsit)
4.07    Tony Gonzalez    (Bryan Warncke)
4.08    Tim Hightower    (Adam Locke)
4.09    Wes Welker    (Dale Grose)
4.10    Kevin Smith    (Mike Peterson)
4.11    T.J. Houshmandzadeh    (Mark Schnzing)
4.12    Tony Romo    (Mark Fisher)
5.01    Roy Williams    (Mark Fisher)
5.02    Joseph Addai    (Mark Schnzing)
5.03    DeSean Jackson    (Mike Peterson)
5.04    Santonio Holmes    (Dale Grose)
5.05    Ben Roethlisberger    (Adam Locke)
5.06    Lee Evans    (Bryan Warncke)
5.07    Donald Driver    (Chris Adsit)
5.08    Darren McFadden    (Tony Nienaber)
5.09    Devin Hester    (Jason Gingerich)
5.10    Ronnie Brown    (Adam London)
5.11    Hines Ward    (Stewart Kuehne)
5.12    Darren Sproles    (Jim O'Brien)
6.01    Derrick Ward    (Jim O'Brien)
6.02    Jason Witten    (Stewart Kuehne)
6.03    Brandon Marshall    (Adam London)
6.04    Bernard Berrian    (Jason Gingerich)
6.05    Marshawn Lynch    (Tony Nienaber)
6.06    Braylon Edwards    (Chris Adsit)
6.07    Stephen Gostkowski    (Bryan Warncke)
6.08    Larry Johnson    (Adam Locke)
6.09    Willis McGahee    (Dale Grose)
6.10    Matt Ryan    (Mike Peterson)
6.11    Reggie Bush    (Mark Schnzing)
6.12    Jonathan Stewart    (Mark Fisher)
7.01    Eddie Royal    (Mark Fisher)
7.02    Carson Palmer    (Mark Schnzing)
7.03    Thomas Jones    (Mike Peterson)
7.04    Kevin Walter    (Dale Grose)
7.05    Lance Moore    (Adam Locke)
7.06    Chris Henry    (Bryan Warncke)
7.07    Steve Breaston    (Chris Adsit)
7.08    Visanthe Shiancoe    (Tony Nienaber)

--Andy Richardson

Readers' Comments

Add a Comment

Already a registered user? Please sign in to add comments.

To add comments, you must become a registered user of our site. To register, please click here.

Fantasy Index Weekly


Order your Fantasy Baseball Index 2012 now

Fantasy Baseball Index, our 116-page fantasy draft annual, includes six separate one-page cheat sheets for 4x4 and 5x5 leagues -- AL-only, NL-only and combined -- Rotisserie dollar values, stat projections, depth charts, expanded coverage of minor league prospects, three-year stats, expert opinions, strategy, team-by-team analysis and more.

AVAILABLE NOW! Order your copy and get it right away.

Order your copy now.

Past Articles

More

Toolbox