Members

Defensive Notes

Back to homepage

No Defense For These Stars

Posted Nov. 07 at 03:59 AM

Last week we had the Chargers’ fantasy defense ranked in our weekly top 5. They were playing extremely well, and were headed to Minnesota to face a one-dimensional Vikings offense. It made a lot of sense, except for the fact that that single dimension was named Adrian Peterson.

You don’t want to overrate one game, but you don’t have to: This was the second time this season that Peterson had rushed for 200-plus yards and 3 TDs – it would probably be more if Brad Childress hadn’t inexplicably limited the rookie to just 12 carries on two occasions this season. Peterson is now officially in the realm of players you don’t want to start a defense against, up there with LaDainian Tomlinson, Peyton Manning and the New England Patriots. This week Peterson faces a Packers defense he went for over 100 yards against on just 12 carries back in week 4. You can’t drop a defense playing as well as the Packers are too far, but Peterson’s presence alone knocks Green Bay down several spots in our rankings. They’ll have to stop him before they can rack up many sacks or interceptions this week.

Fortunately, there are other options, some of which might even be available in your league:

Seattle: The Seahawks aren’t very good, but they do get after the quarterback (No. 6 in sacks), and they achieved that ranking in part by sacking San Francisco quarterbacks 6 times back in week 4. Guess who the Seahawks face this week, in Seattle? An excellent matchup for this defense. As a bonus, they’ve got 2 return touchdowns, too.

Arizona and Detroit: They face each other, which makes it reasonable to think only one of these defenses will have a good day. But there’s a lot to recommend in the matchup for both clubs. No one has allowed more sacks or committed more fumbles than the Lions (who also lead the league in forcing turnovers). Only three teams have thrown more interceptions and only two have committed more fumbles than the Cardinals. Jon Kitna and Kurt Warner in the same game! You probably can’t go wrong with either of these defenses this week.

New Orleans: The Saints? Only nine teams have fewer sacks and only four have fewer interceptions than the Saints. Their lofty ranking must have something to do with the matchup, and so it does: at home against the winless Rams. Unless you think the Rams managed to cure everything that ailed them during their bye last week, consider starting the Saints in this matchup.

Atlanta: The Falcons face the Panthers. David Carr can’t play, Vinny Testaverde can’t move, and third-stringer Matt Moore is an undrafted rookie who the Cowboys cut in the preseason. On sack potential alone (the Titans racked up 7 against Carolina on Sunday), you have to look favorably upon the Falcons’ chances this week.

As it turns out, it’s a particularly good week to start one of these lesser defenses, what with all the matchup problems for several quality fantasy groups this week. The Colts and Chargers are playing each other; not a great matchup for either defense. The Patriots are on a bye, the Steelers are facing a Browns offense that has come a long way since struggling against them in week 1 (with Charlie Frye at quarterback), and the banged-up Ravens are facing a Bengals team that has had some success against them in recent years, including back in week 1. With them playing at home, you may be hard-pressed to bench a fantasy staple like the Steelers or Ravens, but given the other attractive options, it’s an above-average week to think about it.

- Andy Richardson

Readers' Comments

Add a Comment

Already a registered user? Please sign in to add comments.

To add comments, you must become a registered user of our site. To register, please click here.

Fantasy Index Weekly

Fantasy Football Index 2008 and cheat sheet updates have been added to the online store.

Sign up now and rule your draft with Fantasy Index Cheat Sheet Updates.

Subscribe now.

Toolbox

  • Scheduletron
    Team-by-team difficulty of schedule -- with a twist. Strength of schedule rankings for the 2008 season. Updated March 18, 2008.
  • BASEBALL Internet UPDATE - Click on the BASEBALL tab at top to go to the baseball front page
    FREE to readers of Fantasy Baseball Index. Have your copy of the magazine at hand to find the free password.
  • Last Week's Weekly
    Take a look at our advice and predictions from last week's edition of the Fantasy Index Weekly.
  • Internet UPDATE
    FREE to readers of Fantasy Football Index. Have your copy of the magazine at hand to find the free password.
  • Fantasy Index Mock Drafts
    The teams assembled in our mock drafts and mock auction competed during the season (details). See the standings, rosters and weekly scores:
  • Newspaper Links
  • NFL Schedules: 2007 Regular and Preseason
  • Fantasy League Schedules
  • Fantasy Products
    Links to fantasy sports products and services available through the Web.
  • 2007 Auction values
    FREE to the readers of Fantasy Football Index. Have your copy of the magazine handy to find the password.
  • Projected 2007 Stats
    FREE to the readers of Fantasy Football Index. Have your copy of the magazine handy to find the password.
  • How to Play Fantasy Football
    A sample charter to use to start your own league.
  • The Birth of Fantasy Football
    From the archives of Fantasy Football Index, a story about our game's creation in 1962.