Members

Viva Murillo!


Back to homepage

Rules of trading

Posted Oct. 20 at 02:13 AM

When making trades, you should remember "Fight Club." The first rule of Fight Club is that you do not talk about fight club. It's also the second rule; it's that important. Well, trading is almost as simple:

The first rule of trading is that there are no rules. That's also rule number two and three.

It would insult your intelligence to try and pretend there and hard and fast rules to trading. That wouldn't make any sense, no matter what anyone says. Trading involves individuals with different personalities in a variety of situations. There's no way one particular method is going to work most of the time. Aside from not being a jerk, you can pretty much try whatever you think will work in your favor. Part of league dynamics is dealing with different owners who may or may not be willing to help you improve your team. That's part of the fun, really.

Still, it's worth discussing for a moment, because we're at that part of the season where some teams need to string together some wins. If you have one of them, the waiver wire alone probably won't provide everything you need to right the ship. That means you have to look for a trading partner who can help you get those wins. I don't consider the following advice adhering to any rules; they're just things that might not seem intuitive but could help you get something done. But that's as far as it goes. Always remember the first rule of trading.

Trade with the best teams. I know it makes sense to find another owner who needs something and work together to help each other out. But those teams are as desperate as you are. They need a spark and they want something great for their players -- just like you. And like you, they probably over-value what they have. It might be difficult to find something that works for both parties.

But a top team is in a different situation. If they're 7-0 or 6-1, they already have an eye toward the playoffs. They're looking at weeks 15 and 16 and trying to set themselves up as strongly as possible in those weeks. That's where you come in. A lesser player with a great schedule might be more valuable to those owners, and they might part with some of their depth in order to get those favorable match-ups. They also might be interested in ditching some players with poor playoff match-ups, enabling you to get more value for your guys.

Now, the downside is that you end up with players that don't look as promising during the playoff weeks. Well, so what? At this point you don't have the luxury of worrying about week 15 and 16. You just have to get there and worry about it later. Right now, all you care about is weeks 8-14. When I have a top team I'm definitely willing to make a trade I wouldn't make in week 3 based strictly on the playoff match-up. Since you and the other owner have different goals, you value players differently -- and that can work to your advantage.

Tout the guys without byes. If you trade with someone who also needs some wins, offer guys already past their bye and ask for guys who still have a bye coming up. I know that might sound silly because you get them for one less week. But Patriots, Vikings and Texans can be very valuable to you, even if you get one fewer game. I think some owners overweigh the importance of byes, and it might help you get a deal done that brings you a superior player. It's a risk, but if it pans out you get better performance for six weeks. That's better than a lesser performer for seven, although not everyone sees it that way. Take advantage of that.

I'm not saying those tips will get a deal done, but like I said -- there are no rules. At this point in the season, you need to try whatever might work. Hopefully the net result is a couple extra wins and a playoff berth. Good luck this week.

You can reach Michael Murillo at vivamurillo@gmail.com.

Readers' Comments

Posted by ROBERT JOHNSON | Oct. 20 at 02:02 PM

And if you are behind in the standings, try to get a receiver to double up with your QB -- one of the best ways to snag that crucial extra win down the stretch. Hey, if they don't connect, you were down anyway.

Posted by PETER DEBIASE | Oct. 21 at 12:19 AM

I used a strategy last week in a ppr league that I think improved my team long term. I targeted an owner who was 1-4 with bye week issues and offered Westbrook and Gates for Ronnie Brown and Greg Olsen. I know that Olsen is a probably a downgrade from Gates, but I had seen reports out of CHI during the bye that Turner was looking to get him more involved and it appears that he followed through on that on Sunday night. I think Ronnie is a big upgrade over Westbrook on a team that is totally committed to the run and with how many touches he gets in both the base offense and wildcat formations. Any thoughts on this strategy and particularly on the aforementioned trade? Thanks.

Posted by MICHAEL MURILLO | Oct. 21 at 05:08 AM

Peter, I like the idea of trying to improve your team and looking at whoever might help you do it. In a PPR league I don't feel as great about the deal but I follow your thinking about getting Olsen and Brown. I also think Brown has less injury risk and you can't discount that with Westbrook. Overall I don't see a huge advantage for either side but if you're right about Olsen long-term it would really tip that in your favor. Good luck going forward.

Posted by MICHAEL MURILLO | Oct. 21 at 05:10 AM

Robert, that's a good point as well. I often do that on draft day as well. In one league I have Brady, Moss and Welker. It's been dicey so far but I'm not complaining about last week's performance. I would say in the right circumstances, a team looking to trade can help themselves by doubling up on a team. Good call.

Add a Comment

Already a registered user? Please sign in to add comments.

To add comments, you must become a registered user of our site. To register, please click here.

Fantasy Index Weekly


Order your Fantasy Baseball Index 2012 now

Fantasy Baseball Index, our 116-page fantasy draft annual, includes six separate one-page cheat sheets for 4x4 and 5x5 leagues -- AL-only, NL-only and combined -- Rotisserie dollar values, stat projections, depth charts, expanded coverage of minor league prospects, three-year stats, expert opinions, strategy, team-by-team analysis and more.

AVAILABLE NOW! Order your copy and get it right away.

Order your copy now.

Past Articles

More

Toolbox