Members

Factoid


Back to homepage

Ugly recent history for mid- to late-round QBs

Posted Apr. 26 at 09:08 PM

Dynasty owners may be considering some of the college quarterbacks taken in the mid- to later rounds of last weekend's NFL draft. John Skelton, Tony Pike, and Dan LeFevour were some of the "name" college passers taken from the fourth round on.

If the past decade is any indication, though, none of those guys will amount to anything beyond journeyman backup and occasional starter in the NFL. Since Tom Brady was selected in the 6th round back in 2000 and went on to become a future Hall of Famer, it's been a long dry spell for quarterbacks selected outside the third round.

Here are the 69 quarterbacks selected from the fourth round on in 2001 through 2009. The most successful ones to this point are in bold. It may be too early to write off some of last year's picks, but then again it might not. When fourth-rounder David Garrard is the biggest name among those quarterbacks, you know that the future prospects are dim for Skelton, Pike and Co.

Year   Rd   Pick   Player, Team
2009    4    101    Stephen McGee, Cowboys
2009    5    151    Rhett Bomar, Giants
2009    5    171    Nate Davis, 49ers
2009    6    174    Tom Brandstater, Broncos
2009    6    178    Mike Teel, Seahawks
2009    6    196    Keith Null, Rams
2009    6    201    Curtis Painter, Colts
2008    5    137    John David Booty, Vikings
2008    5    156    Dennis Dixon, Steelers
2008    5    160    Josh Johnson, Buccaneers
2008    5    162    Erik Ainge, Jets
2008    6    186    Colt Brennan, Washington
2008    6    198    Andre Woodson, Giants
2008    7    209    Matt Flynn, Packers
2008    7    223    Alex Brink, Texans
2007    5    151    Jeff Rowe, Bengals
2007    5    174    Troy Smith, Ravens
2007    6    205    Jordan Palmer, Washington
2007    7    217    Tyler Thigpen, Vikings
2006    5    148    Ingle Martin, Packers
2006    5    164    Omar Jacobs, Steelers
2006    6    193    Reggie McNeal, Bengals
2006    6    194    Bruce Gradkowski, Buccaneers
2006    7    223    D.J. Shockley, Falcons
2005    4    106    Kyle Orton, Bears
2005    4    121    Stefan Lefors, Panthers
2005    5    145    Dan Orlovsky, Lions
2005    5    152    Adrian McPherson, Saints
2005    6    213    Derek Anderson, Ravens
2005    7    229    James Kilian, Kansas City
2005    7    230    Matt Cassel, Patriots
2005    7    250    Ryan Fitzpatrick, Rams
2004    4    106    Luke McCown, Browns
2004    5    148    Craig Krenzel, Bears
2004    6    185    Andy Hall, Eagles
2004    6    187    Josh Harris, Ravens
2004    6    193    Jim Sorgi, Colts
2004    6    201    Jeff Smoker, Rams
2004    7    202    John Navarre, Cardinals
2004    7    217    Cody Pickett 49ers
2004    7    218    Casey Bramlet, Bengals
2004    7    225    Matt Mauck, Broncos
2004    7    248    B.J. Symons, Texans
2004    7    250    Bradlee Van Pelt, Broncos
2003    4    110    Seneca Wallace, Seahawks
2003    5    163    Brian St. Pierre, Steelers
2003    6    192    Drew Henson, Texans
2003    6    200    Brooks Bollinger, Jets
2003    6    201    Kliff Kingsbury, Patriots
2003    7    232    Gibran Hamdan, Washington
2003    7    241    Ken Dorsey, 49ers
2002    4    108    David Garrard, Jaguars
2002    4    117    Rohan Davey, Patriots
2002    5    137    Randy Fasani, Panthers
2002    5    158    Kurt Kittner, Falcons
2002    5    163    Brandon Doman, 49ers
2002    5    164    Craig Nall, Packers
2002    6    186    J.T. O'Sullivan, Saints
2002    6    205    Steve Bellisari, Rams
2002    7    216    Seth Burford, Chargers
2002    7    232    Jeff Kelly, Seahawks
2002    7    236    Wes Pate, Ravens
2001    5    106    Chris Weinke, Panthers
2001    5    109    Sage Rosenfels, Washington
2001    5    125    Jesse Palmer, Giants
2001    6    149    Mike McMahon, Lions
2001    6    155    A.J. Feeley, Eagles
2001    7    172    Josh Booty, Seahawks
2001    7    177    Josh Heupel, Dolphins

--Andy Richardson

Readers' Comments

Posted by DAVID GARRICK | Apr. 27 at 03:21 AM

Shocking that Kyle Orton is not in bold, but A.J. Feeley and Seneca Wallace are. Maybe Andy is a Raiders fan who hates the Broncos.

Posted by ANDY RICHARDSON | Apr. 27 at 03:50 AM

Orton of course should have been. It's fixed now. Sorry. I actually don't like the Broncos very much, but that wasn't a factor.

Add a Comment

Already a registered user? Please sign in to add comments.

To add comments, you must become a registered user of our site. To register, please click here.

Fantasy Index Weekly


Order your Fantasy Baseball Index 2012 now

Fantasy Baseball Index, our 116-page fantasy draft annual, includes six separate one-page cheat sheets for 4x4 and 5x5 leagues -- AL-only, NL-only and combined -- Rotisserie dollar values, stat projections, depth charts, expanded coverage of minor league prospects, three-year stats, expert opinions, strategy, team-by-team analysis and more.

AVAILABLE NOW! Order your copy and get it right away.

Order your copy now.

Past Articles

More

Toolbox