Members

Factoid

Back to homepage

Plenty of first-round busts among QBs

Posted Mar. 05 at 01:11 PM

The Falcons cut Joey Harrington today. They released Byron Leftwich a few weeks back. It serves as a reminder that just because a quarterback is selected in the first round – even with a top-10 pick – doesn’t mean he’s necessarily ever going to amount to anything.

Consider the following chart, which shows the 30 quarterbacks who’ve attempted at least 700 passes in the last three years. They’re ordered by their NFL passer rating. On that chart, the bottom nine guys are all former first-round picks (and of those nine, only two are securely employed with the teams that drafted them. But of the top 12 guys on the list, only four are former first-round picks.

That’s food for thought for teams like the Falcons and Dolphins, who might be considering using a high selection on Matt Ryan of Boston College. On the following chart, former first-round picks are listed in bold.

Rating Quarterback
100.9 Peyton Manning
99.7 Tom Brady
96.5 Tony Romo
93.6 Carson Palmer
91.6 Drew Brees
91.0 Ben Roethlisberger
90.9 David Garrard
89.9 Donovan McNabb
89.5 Matt Hasselbeck
88.2 Kurt Warner
87.7 Jake Delhomme
86.4 Marc Bulger
86.4 Philip Rivers
86.1 Mark Brunell
83.5 Trent Green
82.5 Chad Pennington
81.4 Jake Plummer
80.9 Steve McNair
79.3 Jon Kitna
79.1 Brett Favre
78.9 Brad Johnson
77.8 J.P. Losman
76.8 David Carr
75.6 Eli Manning
74.4 Michael Vick
73.3 Kerry Collins
72.3 Joey Harrington
70.9 Rex Grossman
69.0 Vince Young
63.5 Alex Smith

--Ian Allan

Readers' Comments

Add a Comment

Already a registered user? Please sign in to add comments.

To add comments, you must become a registered user of our site. To register, please click here.

Fantasy Index Weekly

Fantasy Football Index 2008 and cheat sheet updates have been added to the online store.

Sign up now and rule your draft with Fantasy Index Cheat Sheet Updates.

Subscribe now.

Past Articles

Toolbox

  • Scheduletron
    Team-by-team difficulty of schedule -- with a twist. Strength of schedule rankings for the 2008 season. Updated March 18, 2008.
  • BASEBALL Internet UPDATE - Click on the BASEBALL tab at top to go to the baseball front page
    FREE to readers of Fantasy Baseball Index. Have your copy of the magazine at hand to find the free password.
  • Last Week's Weekly
    Take a look at our advice and predictions from last week's edition of the Fantasy Index Weekly.
  • Internet UPDATE
    FREE to readers of Fantasy Football Index. Have your copy of the magazine at hand to find the free password.
  • Fantasy Index Mock Drafts
    The teams assembled in our mock drafts and mock auction competed during the season (details). See the standings, rosters and weekly scores:
  • Newspaper Links
  • NFL Schedules: 2007 Regular and Preseason
  • Fantasy League Schedules
  • Fantasy Products
    Links to fantasy sports products and services available through the Web.
  • 2007 Auction values
    FREE to the readers of Fantasy Football Index. Have your copy of the magazine handy to find the password.
  • Projected 2007 Stats
    FREE to the readers of Fantasy Football Index. Have your copy of the magazine handy to find the password.
  • How to Play Fantasy Football
    A sample charter to use to start your own league.
  • The Birth of Fantasy Football
    From the archives of Fantasy Football Index, a story about our game's creation in 1962.