Members

Andy Richardson

Back to homepage

Breakout wideouts? Look at year 2, not 3

Posted Apr. 21 at 10:09 AM

There's a popular belief that wideouts break out in their third seasons in the league, and that was certainly true of Roddy White a year ago. White looked like a bust in his first two seasons, but was a legitimate No. 1 in 2007.

Based on some recent numbers, though, White's third-season emergence looks like a bit of an anomaly. Of late it appears that if wide receivers are going to amount to anything in the league, they'll prove it by their second seasons, not their third.

From 2002-2005, there were 52 wide receivers taken in the first three rounds of the draft. Of that group, 14 had posted 800-plus receiving yards or 7-plus TDs by their second seasons. Only 4 -- White, Ashley Lelie, Kevin Curtis and Michael Jenkins -- waited until their third seasons before hitting one of those totals (and in the case of Jenkins and Lelie, those look like flukes). Breakout seasons in their third year? How about the notion that in recent years, with few exceptions, if a guy doesn't break out by his second season, he probably never will.

Now look at the wideouts drafted in the first: three rounds in 2006, organized in descending order by their receiving yards a year ago:

Santonio Holmes 942, 8 TDs
Greg Jennings 920, 12 TDs
Derek Hagan 373, 2 TDs
Sinorice Moss 225, 0 TDs
Maurice Stovall 86, 1 TDs
Willie Reid 54, 0 TDs
Chad Jackson 0, 0 TDs
Travis Wilson 0, 0 TDs
Brandon Williams 0, 0 TDs

Holmes and Jennings, of course, come off breakout campaigns -- in their second seasons. Will any of the other players emerge in their third? It doesn't look good.

At a glance, then, it looks a lot more likely that the breakout wide receivers in 2008 won't be third-year players, but second-year guys. Here are your candidates -- and there are plenty of them -- from the first three rounds last year (organized by draft position). In some cases (bold), those players look like potential fantasy starters already.

Calvin Johnson, Lions
Ted Ginn Jr., Dolphins
Dwayne Bowe, Kansas City
Robert Meachem, Saints
Craig Davis, Chargers
Anthony Gonzalez, Colts
Sidney Rice, Vikings
Dwayne Jarrett, Panthers
Steve Smith, Giants
Jacoby Jones, Texans
Yamon Figurs, Ravens
Laurent Robinson, Falcons
Jason Hill, 49ers
James Jones, Packers
Mike Walker, Jaguars
Paul Williams, Titans
Johnnie Lee Higgins, Raiders

Readers' Comments

Add a Comment

Already a registered user? Please sign in to add comments.

To add comments, you must become a registered user of our site. To register, please click here.

Fantasy Index Weekly

Fantasy Football Index 2008 is AVAILABLE NOW!

Fantasy Football Index includes 220 pages of player ratings, team analysis, stat projections, defensive player analysis, unique stat charts, sleeper picks, rule suggestions, offensive line analysis, and more. And don't forget to order your Fantasy Index Cheat Sheet Updates so they'll be ready and waiting when it's time for your draft or auction.

Sign up now and rule your draft with Fantasy Index Cheat Sheet Updates.

Subscribe now.

Toolbox

  • Scheduletron
    Team-by-team difficulty of schedule -- with a twist. Strength of schedule rankings for the 2008 season. Updated March 18, 2008.
  • BASEBALL Internet UPDATE - Click on the BASEBALL tab at top to go to the baseball front page
    FREE to readers of Fantasy Baseball Index. Have your copy of the magazine at hand to find the free password.
  • Last Week's Weekly
    Take a look at our advice and predictions from last week's edition of the Fantasy Index Weekly.
  • Internet UPDATE
    FREE to readers of Fantasy Football Index. Have your copy of the magazine at hand to find the free password.
  • Fantasy Index Mock Drafts
    The teams assembled in our mock drafts and mock auction competed during the season (details). See the standings, rosters and weekly scores:
  • Newspaper Links
  • NFL Schedules: 2007 Regular and Preseason
  • Fantasy League Schedules
  • Fantasy Products
    Links to fantasy sports products and services available through the Web.
  • 2007 Auction values
    FREE to the readers of Fantasy Football Index. Have your copy of the magazine handy to find the password.
  • Projected 2007 Stats
    FREE to the readers of Fantasy Football Index. Have your copy of the magazine handy to find the password.
  • How to Play Fantasy Football
    A sample charter to use to start your own league.
  • The Birth of Fantasy Football
    From the archives of Fantasy Football Index, a story about our game's creation in 1962.