Members

Ian Allan

Back to homepage

Is Crumpler too old to post big numbers?

Posted Apr. 25 at 04:27 PM

I have interest in Alge Crumpler, who signed with the Titans a few weeks back. He’s one of the better pass-catching tight ends in the league, and he should see a lot more passes in Tennessee’s offense than he saw in Atlanta last year. With a revised offense, the Falcons underused him last year.

Crumpler was a Pro Bowler in each of the four previous seasons. In his previous three seasons, he averaged 53 receiving yards per game, with 19 TDs in 46 games.

The Titans are bringing back Mike Heimerdinger as their offensive coordinator, and he made nice use of Frank Wycheck in his early years with Tennessee.

My No. 1 concern with Crumpler is his age. He’s 30, and he’s had a lot of knee issues in recent years. The tight end position isn’t like wide receiver; guys are getting physically pounded on every play, and they don’t tend to play until their 34, 35 like wide receivers.

It got me wondering: which wears out first, a tight end or a running back? Where do we set that expiration date?

After looking at it further, I think tight ends last slightly longer than running backs. Consider the following numbers:

In the last 15 years, 62 tight ends have had at least 700 receiving yards in a season, and 11 of those guys were at least 30 years old. More than a sixth, which isn’t bad.

Compare that to running backs. I took the top 62 guys of the last 15 years – players who’ve run for over 1,400 yards. Of that group, only four were 30-plus years old. That may not be a complete, entirely scientific study, but I believe tight ends last a little longer than running backs.

Now different guys age differently. Crumpler is 30, but he might be a little older than the typical player that age, because of his history of knee problems. But my hunch is that he’s going to be a pretty good player. I’m projecting him to start 15 games – fewer than most of the top tight end prospects – and I expect him to wind up about No. 8 at that position on my board.

—Ian Allan

Readers' Comments

Add a Comment

Already a registered user? Please sign in to add comments.

To add comments, you must become a registered user of our site. To register, please click here.

Fantasy Index Weekly

Order the week 6 edition of FANTASY INDEX WEEKLY

  • A no-name tight end to pick up in your league.
  • A nobody wide receiver who could help you this week.
  • A lesser running back who should put up surprising numbers this week.

Also

-- Notes for all 32 teams.
-- Analysis of all 16 games.
-- Forecasts for how every player will do in this week's games


Pick better starters with our weekend matchup preview. Learn which top players may be shut down and which sleepers may overachieve this week. Revised player rankings for each week's games for three scoring systems. One extra win per season may be the difference between finishing in the money and missing the playoffs.

Buy the Fantasy Index Weekly | Log In


Weekly


September 30 ReDrafter is available

The in-season version of the Fantasy Index Cheat Sheet -- the ReDrafter -- is perfect for scouting free agents and evaluating trade offers. Our September 9 cheat sheet includes revised season-long rankings, depth charts, rankings tailored to your scoring system, downloadable stat projections in Excel format and IDP cheat sheets. Only $3!

Buy the ReDrafter | Log In


Past Articles

Toolbox