Suppose I gave you the opportunity to add a rotating player to your fantasy roster. Deal goes like this: If a receiver (any receiver in the league) goes for 150 yards in a game, he then starts for your fantasy team the following week. Would you be interested in such an offer? Would it be an improvement over putting one player in that spot for the entire season?

Last year, believe it or not, it would have been a significant downgrade. There were 30 such players in 2016, and in their following 30 games, those guys combined to catch only 4 touchdowns (which hardly seems possible). They also averaged only 4.4 catches and 54 yards, operating at below the pace of a 1,000-yard receiver.

Weird.

I started looking into this when scouting Julio Jones. He went for 253 yards and 2 TDs last week, and I was wondering whether that might indicate that he would be either good or bad in his upcoming game. When looking at his past 10 games over 160 yards, I noticed that he scored only one touchdown in those 10 upcoming games.

Should we attempt to ride the hot hand with a good receiver? That strategy paid off nicely last week with Keenan Allen. Or is the smarter move to figure that when a player has a big game, that makes it less likely that he’ll star again the following week – perhaps opponents will key on him more.

I decided to expand the study, looking at all receivers in the last two years who’ve gone over 150 yards – then look at what happened to them in their following games. The findings were more positive for the 2015 season; those receivers averaged 5.7 catches and 77 yards in their next games, with 16 TDs (in 35 games).

But overall, these kind of players haven’t been as dominant as I would expect.

In the last two years, 65 players have gone over 150 yards (actually 70, but five occurred in Week 17, and I’m leaving those games out). Only 12 of those players (less than 20 percent) went for 100-plus yards the next week. An equal number finished with fewer than 30 yards.

Only 16 of these 65 players (about a quarter) scored in their next game. (Four of the players scored 2 TDs.)

Overall, these players averaged 5.1 catches and 66 yards in their next games. If you had a full season’s worth of them, they’d finish with 81 catches, 1,058 yards and 5 TDs.

WEEK AFTER GAMES WITH 150-PLUS YARDS
YearWkPlayerOppNoYdsTD
20152Keenan Allenat Cin.2160
20153Steve SmithCin.131862
20153Antonio Brownat St.L.111080
20153Allen Robinsonat N.E.4680
20154A.J. GreenK.C.7820
20154Julio JonesHou.4380
20154Steve Smithat Pitt.4240
20155DeAndre HopkinsInd.111690
20156DeAndre Hopkinsat Jac.101482
20157Keenan AllenOak.9890
20157Calvin JohnsonMinn.5861
20157John BrownBalt.4651
20158Mike Evansat Atl.3480
20158T.Y. Hiltonat Car.1150
20159Julio Jonesat S.F.101370
20159Demaryius Thomasat Ind.5500
201510Antonio BrownClev.101392
201510Mike EvansDall.81260
201510Alshon Jefferyat St.L.3230
201510Sammy Watkinsat NYJ3140
201511Martavis Bryantat Sea.5691
201512Julio JonesMinn.5560
201513Sammy WatkinsHou.31091
201513Jeremy Maclinat Oak.9952
201513Markus WheatonInd.3501
201513Jarvis LandryBalt.250
201514Allen RobinsonInd.140
201515Odell BeckhamCar.6761
201516Jordan MatthewsWash.61041
201516Emmanuel SandersCin.4671
201516Mike EvansChi.4610
201516Antonio Brownat Balt.7610
201516DeSean Jacksonat Phil.4400
201517Julio JonesN.O.91490
201517Allen Robinsonat Hou.51080
20162Willie Sneadat NYG5541
20162A.J. Greenat Pitt.2380
20163Stefon Diggsat Car.4400
20164Marvin Jonesat Chi.5740
20164Doug Baldwinat NYJ4540
20164T.Y. HiltonJac.(UK)7421
20165A.J. Greenat Dall.4500
20165Julio Jonesat Den.2290
20166Greg Olsenat N.O.6940
20166T.Y. Hiltonat Hou.3490
20167Golden TateWash.6930
20167Rob Gronkowskiat Pitt.4931
20167Brandin Cooksat K.C.7581
20167Odell BeckhamL.A.(UK)5490
20168A.J. GreenWas.(UK)91210
20168Julio JonesG.B.3290
20169Amari CooperDen.6560
201610Mike EvansChi.4660
201610Robert Woodsat Cin.3410
201611Antonio BrownClev.8760
201611Davante Adamsat Wash.3420
201611Stefon DiggsAriz.6370
201613Emmanuel Sandersat Jac.3280
201616Brandin CooksT.B.5980
201617Jordy Nelsonat Det.6660
201617Odell Beckhamat Wash.5440
201617Doug Baldwinat S.F.2440
201617Sammy Watkinsat NYJ4310
201617Travis Kelceat S.D.180
201617Adam ThielenChi.170

—Ian Allan