Jacksonville’s defense comes off a remarkably good season, and they’ve amassed an impressive bundle of talent. But does it make sense to select this defense three rounds before the others next summer in drafts?

The talent is impressive. The team has been bad for a lot of years, allowing them to draft a lot of good players. Jalen Ramsey and Dante Fowler are outstanding, and Myles Jack looks like a second-round steal. Jack might have been a top-5 pick, but there were questions about his knee. The strip-fumble of Dion Lewis on Sunday was probably the most impressive defensive play of the postseason.

They’ve also been investing in defensive free agents, and they’ve been hitting on those purchases. A.J. Bouye, Calais Campbell, Malik Jackson, Barry Church, Tashaun Gibson. This defense is stacked.

The Jaguars were remarkably productive in the regular season, with 8 touchdowns (including one on a punt return), 55 sacks and 33 takeaways.

Using standard basic fantasy scoring, Jacksonville scored 20 more points than any other team on defensive (and special teams) plays. In this century, only eight defenses have scored more points in a season.

I expect Jacksonville will rank in the top 3 on everyone’s draft board next summer. (Today, they would be No. 1 on mine.)

But history tells us that it’s tough for such defenses to actually come through and meet expectations. There’s roster turnover and injuries, some players will underperform, and opponents adjust game plans – when a defense is generating lots of sacks and interceptions, that affects game plans of opponents.

Since 2000, 42 other defenses have scored at least 150 points (fantasy points) in a season. Those great defenses than averaged 44 fewer points the next year. All but four of them scored at least 20 fewer points. Collectively, they averaged 3 fewer touchdowns, 6 fewer sacks and 9 fewer takeaways.

Of those 42 previous defenses that played really well, only 7 ranked in the top 5 in fantasy scoring the next year. That’s 1-in-6 – the same of picking up a dice and rolling it with the expectation of getting a specific number. Just over a third of those teams (15 of 42) at least ranked in the top 10. But nobody’s using an early pick on a defense hoping to rank 7th in scoring at that position.

I like the Jaguars. I find that I am more willing than most to be one of the first to select a kicker or defense if I feel there’s some value there. But my early guess is that in most fantasy leagues, there will be a couple of owners who are willing to select the Jaguars a little earlier than I will. For me, the price has to be right.

On the chart below, if a defense ranked in the top 10 the next year, it's got a black dot. If it ranked in the top 5, it's got an additional dot.

FANTASY DEFENSES WITH 150 POINTS
YearTeamTDSackTakePointsNextRank
2012• Chicago1041441891299
2000Denver9444418812513
2007San Diego8424818610216
2013Kansas City1147361859225
2004Buffalo10453918511219
2006•• Chicago940441841572-3
2000• Tampa Bay755411811446
2006Baltimore6604018010223
2017Jacksonville85533171??
2014•• Philadelphia1149281711335
2009New Orleans935391679724-26
2003•• New England741411671474-5
2003St. Louis542461668230
2000New Orleans5663516612114
2010• New England936381661326
2003•• Baltimore647411651612
2000Oakland7433716311915
2012New England7374116312411
2004Baltimore9393416111120
2002Philadelphia5563716011016
2001Chicago6483716010321
2009• Philadelphia6443816012510
2001Cleveland5434215910419-20
2002• Tampa Bay643381591288-9
2007New England847311578129
2002Green Bay4434515711613-14
2007• Chicago841331571306-7
2001•• Green Bay452391561573
2007• Minnesota9383115612510
2011Detroit741341537029
2000Baltimore3354915311321-22
2010Arizona10333015310418-19
2003Kansas City7363715210420-22
2012Denver8522415212312
2001• New England7403515212810
2000Tennessee6553015110624
2002New Orleans6393815110619
2017Baltimore74134151??
2011•• Chicago933311511891
2003Tennessee7383415010420-22
2013Seattle4443915010518-21
2012San Diego938281507531
2000Miami3484115012911
2008•• Philadelphia748291501602

—Ian Allan