Sometimes it seems that the worst defense is a good offense. With teams that are putting up plenty of yards and points – think Saints, Patriots, Packers in some recent years – there’s maybe a tendency for opponents to be forced to open up offensively to keep pace. Opponents can (in theory) pick up more garbage-time stats against prevent defenses.

Or is better to target a lesser opponent (Browns, Jets, 49ers, Rams) figuring those teams will generally struggle, in part because they have offenses that can’t stay on the field (giving opponents more opportunities and time of possession).

So I poked around some with the concept of picking a defense not on its own merits, but on the quality of the team’s offense. Is there any merit there? Or are we better (when picking defenses) to focus simply on the defense itself?

The league has had 32 teams for the last 15 years. That’s 480 teams, making for a sizable chunk we can look at.

For this study, I’m looking just at yards gained, rushing and passing (leaving out yards lost on sacks). I took the yards gained for each of those 480 offenses, and then looked at how many yards they allowed going the other way.

The results are modestly interesting. Of the 15 teams ranking No. 1 in offense, those teams had defenses allowing an average of 5,817 yards – the 2nd-most. And the No. 2 offenses allowed an average of 5,913 yards – the most.

The 15 No. 3 offenses also ranked in the bottom-5 defensively, and it seems we’re sort of onto something – maybe there’s something to the idea that teams with good offenses tend to allow more yards (with their games more often becoming shootouts or whatever).

But the results get more random when you look at the other 29 team positions.

Coming in at No. 4, we have teams allowing an average of 5,292 yards (2nd fewest). And the two other slots with the leakiest defenses come not from good offense, but from teams ranking 26th and 31st offensively.

I don’t think there’s anything useful going on here that we can latch onto.

Here are the results of the 480 teams (15 in each of the 32 slots). Teams in bold ranked in the bottom-5 defensive (most total yards). Teams with black dots allowed the fewest total yards.

On average, teams allowed 1,828 rushing yards and 3,770 passing yards per season.

OFFENSE/DEFENSE COMPARISON SINCE 2002
OffRunPassTotalRank
11,7824,0355,81731
21,8244,0885,91332
31,8503,9125,76229
4•1,609•3,683•5,2922
51,6723,9815,65420
61,8773,7525,63017
71,7213,7525,4737
81,8793,8545,73327
91,7293,8015,53011
101,8433,7555,59915
111,8073,7335,54012
12•1,651•3,734•5,3855
131,6573,8585,5169
141,7823,6985,4808
151,7993,7485,54713
161,7633,9605,72325
171,7713,7545,52510
181,8473,7985,64619
191,8183,6335,4516
20•1,735•3,642•5,3783
211,7563,8155,57114
22•1,653•3,599•5,2531
231,9713,6955,66621
24•1,768•3,615•5,3844
251,9383,6715,60916
261,9223,8225,74528
271,8943,7505,64518
282,0483,6525,70023
292,1053,6235,72926
301,9853,6935,67922
312,0423,7665,80930
321,9683,7405,70924

In the last 15 years, eight teams with bottom-5 offenses have ranked in the top-5 defensively (yards only). This includes Houston, Denver and Minnesota last year.

BOTTOM-5 OFFENSES WITH TOP-5 DEFENSES
YearTeamOffRunPassTotalRank
2002Carolina311,6533,3294,9822
2003Buffalo281,6062,9384,5442
2004Washington301,3043,2224,5262
2005Chicago311,6373,1474,7842
2006Oakland322,1442,6314,7753
2016Houston301,5953,4245,0191
2016Denver282,0853,2005,2853
2016Minnesota291,7113,6375,3485

During the same time period, there have been 15 teams with bottom-5 offenses that also ranked in the bottom-5 defensively. Almost twice as many. This includes San Francisco in each of the last two seasons.

BOTTOM-5 OFFENSES WITH BOTTOM-5 DEFENSES
YearTeamOffRunPassTotalRank
2002Detroit301,9674,4046,37131
2003Houston312,3703,8356,20531
2003Atlanta302,3084,0056,31332
2005Buffalo292,2053,5605,76529
2005Houston282,3033,7276,03031
2005San Francisco321,8324,6206,45232
2007Buffalo311,9933,9585,95131
2008Seattle301,8994,3426,24130
2008Detroit282,7543,9076,66132
2009St. Louis292,2013,9136,11429
2009Cleveland322,3144,1496,46332
2010Tennessee281,8514,3046,15528
2010Arizona312,3233,8816,20429
2015San Francisco312,0204,3756,39529
2016San Francisco312,6544,0136,66732

In the last 15 years, only 10 teams have finished seasons with both a top-5 offense and a top-5 defense.

TOP-5 OFFENSES WITH TOP-5 DEFENSES
YearTeamOffRunPassTotalRank
2002Denver31,4893,5885,0775
2004Denver51,5123,2134,7254
2007New England11,5723,3814,9535
2009Green Bay41,3333,4504,7832
2010San Diego11,5003,1354,6351
2012Denver41,4583,5585,0163
2013New Orleans41,7863,4415,2273
2014Denver41,2763,8595,1353
2015Seattle41,3043,5644,8681
2015Arizona21,4603,9575,4175

During the same time period, 16 teams have had top-5 offenses but bottom-5 defenses. This includes Washington last year.

TOP-5 OFFENSES WITH BOTTOM-5 DEFENSES
YearTeamOffRunPassTotalRank
2002Kansas City52,0674,3966,46332
2003Kansas City22,3443,6145,95829
2004Kansas City11,8344,4536,28731
2004Indianapolis22,0374,2326,26930
2004Minnesota32,0064,1306,13629
2008Denver22,3373,7976,13428
2010Houston31,7514,4996,25030
2011New England21,8744,9776,85132
2011Green Bay31,7894,9886,77731
2012New Orleans22,3614,8757,23632
2012Washington51,5324,7206,25229
2013Philadelphia21,6684,9076,57530
2014Philadelphia51,7714,5956,36631
2014New Orleans12,1254,2076,33230
2015New Orleans12,0714,7556,82631
2016Washington31,9164,3836,29928

—Ian Allan